Good governance vital to success of REDD

Good governance vital to success of REDD, says leading forestry research group

Press release: Forest Research and Development Agency and Center for International Forestry Research: 15 January 2010

Payments to developing countries to reduce emissions from deforestation will only succeed if corruption and lack of financial management capacity are addressed, says new report.

BOGOR, INDONESIA (15 January 2009)—As discussions continue post Copenhagen on the future of the world’s forests, a new report from one of the world’s leading forestry research centres says that if proposed REDD (reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation) schemes are to succeed it is essential to address corruption, build financial management capacity and create transparent mechanisms for financial transfers. 

“The prominence of forests in the Copenhagen Accord has demonstrated that REDD can become a reality,” said Frances Seymour, Director General of the Centre for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), headquartered in Indonesia. “But our new report underlines that we should be paying increased attention to the measurement, reporting, and verification of REDD-related financial flows. Many of the countries with the most remaining forest are also those with weak or evolving governance structures to control corruption. We need to build management capacity in order to ensure that REDD funds end up in the pockets of the people who are actually the ones protecting the forest. This doesn’t mean we should stop REDD; the risks of corruption have to be balanced against the risks of no action, which are huge. We have to introduce REDD in phases so that capacity on the ground can catch up with the ambition.”

Tachrir Fathoni, Director General, Forestry Research and Development Agency (FORDA) at the Indonesia’s Ministry of Forestry, who is also a member of CIFOR’s Board of Trustees, is studying the report. “This research has highlighted the serious abuses that dogged forest management in the past,” said Fathoni. “We have made tremendous progress since then and we must continue to learn from this research about how to make the system more transparent, measured and monitored – not just in the REDD sector but in all our financial management. We call upon the international community to support this progress and invest in capacity building at all levels.”

The CIFOR study, Financial governance and Indonesia’s Reforestation Fund during the Soeharto and post-Soeharto periods, 1989–2009: a political economic analysis of lessons for REDD+, reveals details of mismanagement of the Indonesian Reforestation Fund, which was established in 1989 under former President Soeharto and which collected billions of US dollars in levies from timber concessionaires to pay for reforestation. The research found the fund had been subject to financial mismanagement and fraud between 1993 and 1998.

The CIFOR report recommends that Indonesia set up new mechanisms to monitor the money flowing into the country for REDD projects, and to strengthen existing oversight bodies such as the KPK (Indonesian Corruption Commission). Control of the Reforestation Fund has now been transferred to the Ministry of Finance, and anti-corruption bodies such as the KPK and the State Audit Board (BPK) have helped to improve the situation since the fall of Soeharto in 1998, said one of the report’s authors, Ahmad Dermawan.

“We have accepted the report’s conclusions that the Reforestation Fund was partly used for non-forestry purposes or subject to abuses,” said Fathoni, “However, we have learned a great deal since 1999 and have been in the process of developing and improving all aspects of financial governance. We cannot extrapolate the past to the future. We can and will change.”

REDD, as currently envisioned, could eventually transfer US$15-25 billion a year from developed to forest-rich developing countries. These funds would be used to implement policies to control the drivers of deforestation and degradation and to compensate forest owners for foregoing income available from converting forests to other uses. Emissions from the deforestation and degradation of forests are estimated to contribute 15-20 percent of total global emissions, more than the transportation sector contributes. But while REDD is seen as a crucial part of a new global climate pact, there is little consensus among decision makers and interest groups over how the mechanism should be implemented at the national level and below.
 
“If significant payments were to flow today, REDD programs  would be challenged to meet the tests of effectiveness in reducing emissions, efficiency in channelling funds, and equity in distribution,” said Seymour. “Strong, vested interests are driving the conversion of forests to other uses. There are also profound disagreements about who should benefit from REDD schemes, in terms of rights and benefit-sharing among forest communities, private companies, and local and national governments. Those conflicts will take time, money, and political will to sort out. Capacity building at all levels is urgently required. Still, REDD is a vital tool for mitigating climate change and protecting forests. We must embrace these challenges to ensure that it is a success.”

Added Fathoni: “Indonesia is in the process of developing mechanisms for accepting REDD funds that will minimise the possibility of mismanagement.  Unlike the case of the Reforestation Fund prior to 1999, in which the Ministry of Forestry was the sole authority, REDD fund mechanisms will involve multiple institutions, including the Ministry of Finance, the National Planning Board, as well as local government. Transparency will be the most important characteristic of the mechanisms. Indonesia is confident it is on the right track toward controlling drivers of emissions from deforestation and forest degradation through REDD implementation.”

Financial governance and Indonesia’s Reforestation Fund during the Soeharto and post-Soeharto periods, 1989–2009: a political economic analysis of lessons for REDD+ by Barr, C.; Dermawan, A.; Purnomo, H. and Komarudin, H., is available here: http://www.cifor.cgiar.org/Knowledge/Publications/Detail?pid=2886

About the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR)

CIFOR advances human wellbeing, environmental conservation and equity by conducting research to inform policies and practices that affect forests in developing counties. CIFOR helps ensure that decision making that affects forests is based on solid science and principles of good governance, and reflects the perspectives of developing countries and forest-dependent people. CIFOR is one of 15 centres within the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research. For more information, please visit: www.cifor.cgiar.org.

About FORDA, Ministry of Forestry

Established in 1913, the Forest Research and Development Agency (FORDA) is an Indonesian Government institution under the Ministry of Forestry. FORDA supports and informs the Ministry of Forestry toward the successful implementation of its policies by providing reliable, relevant and accurate information based on scientific findings. FORDA’s mission is: i) to provide science and technology that support sustainable and optimal use of forest resources for the people welfare, ii) to coordinate, supervise and evaluate forestry research and development activities, supported by professional human resources and competence research and development institutions, and (iii) to disseminate forestry science and technology for the improvement of value added and competitiveness of forest products.

How Can You Help

There are lots of ways you can support orangutans and help ensure the survival of this precious ape.

Adopt an Orangutan

Adopt an Orangutan

Orangutans are endangered and at risk of extinction. Habitat destruction results in hundreds of orphaned orangutans, who rely on our care every year. You can help by adopting one. Their dedicated ‘nannies’ teach them everything they need to know for when it’s time to release them back to the wild. You can follow their progress through Forest School.

Adopt Now
Make a Donation

Make a Donation

Please help the Orangutans in their struggle for survival. Your donation is important and goes directly to BOS Indonesia. By donating, you are helping bring this noble yet endangered species back from the brink of extinction and on a path to freedom - from rescue to rehabilitation and release.

Donate Now
Visit Our Shop

Visit Our Shop

The perfect gift for any occasion! Choose from our selection of instant gifts that directly support our orangutans. You can buy a wheelbarrow, provide food for an orangutan for two months or lots more. You will receive a certificate, personalised with the name of your choice - perfect gift for you or a friend.

Shop Now